White dentist makes shocking claims to GVO as lawsuit against Jewish Legislator is dismissed, co-defendant still being sued
An openly anti-White politician is no longer being sued for accusing a White dentist of hosting a racist and sexist party. In light of massive payouts and legal fees, the dentist suggests impropriety.
Updated: 19 August 2024 9:20 PM
ROCHESTER, NY - Nicholas Nicosia, DDS released a statement concerning the dismissal of his lawsuit against Monroe County Legislator, Rachel Barnhart.
▪️ Nicosia describes Advocates for Justice’ “cancel campaign” utilized “to terrify the guests at the party.” Further details Jewish Legislator Barnhart’s desire for “endless investigations into a private party.” PLUS: Were White witnesses ignored while massive settlements were paid to disgruntled POCs?
▪️ Catch up with the most recent GVO article on this case
▪️ More on Jewish lawfare organization, Advocates for Justice
Barnhart, who is Jewish, has stated that it’s "time for recourse under SLAPP," but Nicosia says his lawsuit was "not meant to harass or silence anyone," and that her co-defendant, Nate McMurray, Esq. is still being sued.
A SLAPP (Strategic Lawsuit Against Public Participation) is a lawsuit intended to silence critics by burdening them with legal costs, often in cases involving public interest speech or activism.
Barnhart and McMurray’s legal teams could not be reached in time for comment.
The decision was posted publicly yesterday at 10 am by reporter Gino Fanelli.
The court stated that Barnhart's statements were protected "because they summarize or restate allegations in the notice of claim brought on behalf of Defendant McMurray’s client as they relate to the subject party."
McMurray's team argued [screenshot] that their claims were also protected as they related to ongoing legal proceedings. The court opted to postpone their decision on McMurray, showing how some statements were not merely a matter of opinion, but were seemingly "actionable" and not merely "fair and true reports of judicial proceedings."
Hypothetical "fair and true reports" would be protected by N.Y. Civil Rights Law § 74.
The implications of this claim seem to not be lost on Nicosia, who writes, "it is important that the decision correctly found my claim that Nathan McMurray lied about me can now move forward."
McMurray represented firefighter Jones in his lawsuit against the City of Rochester for a variety of issues stemming from a perpetually racist work environment. Jones' lawsuit, which settled recently for "$150K plus four years salary," specifically mentioned a politically-themed party at Nicosia's house in the summer of 2022, attended by Jones while he was on duty.
Nicosia, a witness to the party at his own home, makes some rather damning claims about the nature of Jones' settlement:
"I have reached out repeatedly to City Hall, the Rochester Fire Department, and local politicians, including Ms. Barnhart, to offer to speak with them. My calls were never answered."
-Nicholas Nicosia, DDS.
The presence of Juneteenth party favors, a Trump cutout and a Rachel Barnhart impersonator led Jones to compare his experience to the anti-White, racially themed horror film 'Get Out.'
McMurray is also being sued for defamation by Irondequoit Police Chief, Scott Peters. Peters says McMurray defamed him by alleging his attendance at the very same party and seeking to disrupt his appointment to IPD Chief based on that attendance.
Nicosia also delves into a seemingly odd contradiction; Barnhart's concessions in legal documents that her sole source for the party timeline was McMurray and her refusal to specifically affirm that in writing.
According to Nicosia's lawyer, Michael Thad Allen, Esq., a sworn statement from Barnhart alleging the same would have ended the lawsuit against her as early as October 2023.
The lawsuit was filed in August of that year.
We will release more updates on McMurray, Nicosia, Peters and others as they become available.